” But how could it fail to? The majority of illegal aliens are

Michael Scarpalanda on Arizona Senate Bill 1070

Canada Goose online Craig M. I ran across an interesting article at The Witherspoon Institute on illegal immigration called Arizona, Congress, and the Immigration Mess. And I was hoping that canada goose outlet mall you might comment on some of the points that he makes against SB 1070. Thanks for the consideration! Canada Goose online

cheap Canada Goose And thank your for alerting me to this article by Michael Scarpalanda, who holds the Gene and Elaine Edwards Family Chair in Law at the University of Oklahoma College of Law. Here are some comments. cheap Canada Goose

Canada Goose sale The article begins unpromisingly by referring to “Arizona draconian response” to the problem of illegal immigration. I must immediately protest. To refer to SB 1070 as “draconian” is an egregious misuse of language. One should not toss this word around without knowing what it means. It derives from the name of the first legislator of written laws of Athens, Greece. The harshness of Draco code gave rise to the adjective which properly applied only laws and canada goose vest outlet sanctions that are harsh, cruel, and unreasonable. Now there is nothing draconian about SB 1070 as you may verify for yourself by simply reading it. See also the fact sheet. Canada Goose sale

Canada Goose Jackets Turning now to the article, we read: Canada Goose Jackets

Canada Goose Parka On April 30, 2010, Arizona’s governor signed SB 1070 into law, setting off waves of hyperbolic reactions and counter reactions. Among other things, the law states that “for any lawful contact made by a law enforcement official or agency… where reasonable suspicion exists that the person is an alien who is unlawfully present in the United States, a reasonable attempt shall be made… to determine the immigration status of the person.” An alien unlawfully canada goose stockists uk present can be taken into custody, canada goose outlet charged with a state crime, and transferred to federal custody. Canada Goose Parka

canada goose store Several questions immediately arise. What is “lawful contact”? What constitutes canada goose outlet in canada “reasonable suspicion”? How will canada goose outlet uk sale immigration status be determined? canada goose store

canada goose clearance Scarpalanda fails to mention that a week after canada goose outlet toronto factory Governor Brewer signed into law SB 1070, she signed into law House Bill 2162 which modifies and clarifies the language of 1070, in particular, the phrase “lawful contact.” more on this, together with quotations from 2162, see this post canada goose outlet online store review of mine. canada goose clearance

canada goose When cavils like those that Scarpalanda canada goose factory outlet vancouver raises are made it is pretty good evidence that one is dealing with a liberal who simply does not want immigration laws enforced. Not knowing anything about Scarpalanda, I cannot canada goose outlet london uk know whether this is true in his case. But in the vast majority of cases of liberal leftist hyperventilation over 1070 it is spectacularly clear that one is dealing with open canada goose outlet factory borders types who do not respect the rule of law except when it can be invoked to further the leftist agenda. canada goose outlet montreal canada goose

buy canada goose jacket Although the law forbids using race as the sole determining factor in forming “reasonable suspicion,” the law will undoubtedly have a canada goose outlet toronto location disproportionate impact on Arizona’s Hispanic population, including those who are United States citizens or lawful permanent residents. How could it not? Race, ethnicity, and accent will almost http://www.mycanadagoosejacket.org surely be factors in deciding whether to verify canada goose outlet phone number a person’s immigration or citizenship canada goose outlet uk fake status. buy canada goose jacket

canada goose deals Again, Scarpalanda ignores the 2162 modifications of 1070, in particular, this one: “A law enforcement official or agency of this state or a county, city, town or other political subdivision of this canada goose outlet winnipeg address state may canada goose outlet paypal not solely consider race, color or national origin in implementing the requirements of this subsection except to the extent permitted by the United States or Arizona Constitution.” canada goose deals

canada goose black friday sale Scarpalanda is worried that the new law will have a “disproportionate impact on Arizona population.” But how could it fail to? The majority of illegal aliens are Hispanic! Here we canada goose outlet ontario note the twisted logic of the Politically Correct. These people display an unthinking quota mentality: they think there is something unfair about a law if, when it is enforced, it affects more members of one group than another, or affects a group But to think in this way is to show that one is morally obtuse. Vastly more men than women abuse their spouses. But it is surely no valid argument against laws prohibiting spousal abuse that they disproportionately men. Because more men commit this crime than women, it is to be expected that more men will be Similarly, because more Hispanics than Asians or Blacks or Caucasians violate immigration laws canada goose outlet winnipeg in such southern border states as Arizona, it is to be expected that Hispanics will be disproportionately affected by the enforcement of immigration laws. It is only to be expected, and there is nothing unjust about it. canada goose black friday sale

buy canada goose jacket cheap Despite shoddiness of most canada goose outlet black friday sale of Scarpalanda article (failure to link to the relevant documents, failure to take into consideration the House bill modification of the Senate bill, use of the bad argument just exposed), his positive proposals near the end are actually quite reasonable: secure the borders to stem the tide of future illegals; provide for the legalization of the the large numbers of productive, non criminal canada goose outlet store uk illegals already here; adopt a temporary worker program. buy canada goose jacket canada goose outlet 2015 cheap

canada goose coats But Job One is to secure the border by building and maintaining a physical barrier that from the Pacific Ocean to the Gulf of Mexico. All the better heads agree on this canada goose coats.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mail Icon

Get in Touch

If you are interested in learning more about the full range of our risk advisory services and career opportunities, we look forward to discussing how we might be able to work together.

Contact Us